The Fourth Generation — Story, Setting & Ideas

(0 User reviews) 67

In Category - Historical Psychological Social Fiction

Authors: Besant, Walter, 1836-1901 Digital Source: Project Gutenberg Gutenberg Release Year: 2015 First Publication Year: Not confirmed

Key Word: England -- Social life and customs -- 19th century -- Fiction; Murder -- Fiction; Families -- Fiction Target Reader: Readers of public-domain and historical texts

Book Edition: Project Gutenberg digital edition Book Language: en

Edition facts

Words 90,790

Reading time 395 min

Text sections 9

The catalog record for The Fourth Generation — Story, Setting & Ideas provides practical reading context through 90,790 words, 6 hr 35 min estimated reading time, and 9 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 13.8 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “England -- Social life and customs -- 19th century -- Fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Source: Project Gutenberg record #50177

Walter Besant's novel follows Leonard Campaigne as he investigates a 19th-century murder that haunts his family, blending detective work with a philosophical inquiry into inherited guilt and consequence.

Editorial Edition Score 4.7/5

★★★★★ ★★★★★

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated

Description quality20 pts
Title & short description10 pts
Source metadata20 pts
Text length15 pts
Chapters / structure15 pts
EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

File: pg50177

Read the Text

in fact, by the gardens, and the lawns, and the “glass,” as they must have been in the past. As for the garden of the present, it was difficult even to guess when the hand of man, the spade of the gardener, had last touched any part of the place. Everything was overgrown; weeds covered the ground which had once been beds of asparagus and celery; the strawberry plants fought for existence with thistles, and maintained it, by the sacrifice of fruit; couch grass and those thistles, with shepherd’s-purse and all the weeds of the field, covered and concealed the flower-beds. The lanes and walks were covered ways, long since rendered impassable by reason of branches that had shot across them; the artificial shapes of the box-trees, formerly so trim and precise, showed cloudy and mysterious through the branches which had grown up outside them; the bowling-green was covered with coarse grass never mown from year to year. In the glass houses the doors stood open: the glass was broken; the vines grew wild, pushing their way through the broken panes. There could be no respect possible for a garden in such a condition. Yet, the pity of it! the pity of it! So fine a place as it had been, as it might again become, if gardeners were once more ordered to restore it to its ancient splendours!

If one turned from the garden and walked towards the house, he would notice, first, that the stairs of brick leading to the terrace were a good deal battered and broken; that many bricks had been displaced, that weeds grew between the bricks, that in the balustrade there were places where the square brick pillars were broken away; that if he mounted the stairs, the brick pavement of the terrace showed holes and damaged places here and there; that if he looked at the house itself he would discern there, as well as in the garden, a certain air of neglect and decay. The window-frames wanted painting, the door wanted painting, there were no curtains or blinds visible anywhere; one or two panes of glass were broken, and not even patched. Stately, even in decay, were house and gardens; but the spectator shivered, as one shivers at the sight of age and decay and death hovering over what should still be rejoicing in the strength of manhood.

On this morning, when the cold of winter ushered in the deceitful spring, a man was walking to and fro on the brick terrace. He was a man very far advanced in life. Cold as he was, he wore no overcoat; he had no wrapper or handkerchief round his neck; he wore no gloves.

When one looked more closely, he was not only advanced in years: he was full of years--overfull, running over. His great age was apparent in the innumerable lines of his face; not in the loss of his hair, for his abundant white locks fell flowing, uncut and untrimmed, upon his shoulders, while a full white beard lay over his ample chest. His age was shown by the heightening of the cheek-bones and the increased prominence of the nose, in the sunken mouth, and the thin lips, and the deep-set eyes. But though his face had been roughly handled by time, his frame seemed to have escaped any touch. Old as he was, he bore himself upright still; he walked with a firm, if not an elastic, step; he carried a stick, but did not use it. He was still six feet four, or even more, in stature; his shoulders were still broad, his back was not curved, nor was his huge, strong body bowed, nor were his strong legs bent or weakened. Nothing could be more anomalous than the difference between the man’s face, chipped and lined and covered with curves and diagrams, like an Ordnance Survey map, and his figure, still so strong, so erect, so vigorous.

Continue Reading →

The Fourth Generation opens with a March morning described in precise, unsparing detail: a northeast wind grinds dry branches, the sky is a uniform grey, and the hedges show no flowers, not even the celandine. This bleakness sets the tone for a story that begins not with its protagonist but with a murder inquest. The catalog subjects list England social life, murder, and families, but the excerpts reveal a narrative that is less about domestic customs than about the forensic reconstruction of a crime. The novel's preface explicitly frames the story as an exploration of why the innocent suffer for ancestral sins, proposing consequence rather than punishment. Yet the excerpts show the book grounding this philosophical question in a specific legal document: a coroner's report and trial transcript that Leonard Campaigne reads, which details the 1799 murder of a man in a wood.

A Murder Reconstructed Through Documents

The excerpts devote considerable space to a coroner's inquest and trial report. The narrative does not present the murder as a flashback or dramatic scene; instead, Leonard reads a printed account. The text includes the coroner's verdict of wilful murder against John Dunning, the prisoner's cry of 'No! No! I never done it!', and the magistrate's mechanical commitment. The trial report is given at length, with counsel cross-examining Mr. Campaigne about distances in the wood, the absence of seats, and the improbability of the deceased lingering for two hours. The counsel's argument hinges on a map of the wood and the physical impossibility of the prosecution's timeline. This reliance on documentary evidence—maps, distances, timings—gives the novel a procedural, almost legalistic texture, distinct from a purely psychological family drama.

The Philosophical Frame in the Preface

The preface, dated June 1900, states the story first appeared as a serial in 1899 and was partly rewritten. Besant directly addresses the question 'why the innocent must suffer... for the follies and the sins of their forefathers.' He offers an answer that 'substitutes consequence for punishment' and claims authority from 'the greatest of the Prophets of Israel.' He writes that consequences 'can only affect the body, or the mind, or the social position of the descendants' but cannot do more, and that they 'may be made a ladder for the soul to rise or a weight to drag it down.' This preface is the only place where the novel's thematic argument is stated outright; the excerpts from the main text do not repeat this language, suggesting the story itself may dramatize these ideas through the murder case and its aftermath.

Setting as Evidence: The Wood and the Weather

The opening chapter establishes setting not as atmosphere but as evidence. The March morning is described with a catalog of absences: no signs of spring, no gleams of light, no flowers, no celandine. This precision recurs in the trial, where the counsel asks about the wet grass, muddy path, and the impossibility of sitting on fallen trees. The wood is 'little more than a coppice,' taking five minutes to walk through. The deceased entered at a quick pace, walking for exercise and to inspect fields. The prosecution's theory requires him to have stood in the wet wood for nearly two hours—a scenario the defense calls 'improbable—even impossible.' The setting thus becomes a silent witness, its physical details used to challenge the official story. This attention to the concrete conditions of a place aligns with the novel's interest in consequence: the land itself holds traces of past actions.

Readers should attend to how the novel balances its two registers: the philosophical preface and the gritty legal documents. The excerpts show little of Leonard's personal life or the 'families' subject; the focus is on the 1799 murder and its evidentiary reconstruction. The catalog also lists 'detective-mystery' as a secondary topic, and the trial excerpts indeed read like a detective story in miniature, with the defense counsel building a case from physical improbabilities. The full novel likely interweaves this historical crime with the present-day consequences for the Campaigne family, but the excerpts alone do not reveal how. Approach the text as a work that uses the apparatus of a mystery to explore inherited burden, but be prepared for long passages of documentary reportage.

Some stories sit with you like an old photograph, and Besant’s inherited-guilt mystery does that. It made me think of how The Revolt of the Oyster — Story, Setting & Ideas lingers in the same quiet way, circling consequences we didn’t choose. There’s something tender about watching characters carry that weight, almost like holding a familiar ache.